Nick Dunhill's Workshop - NBR Class J (D29) loco from a N B Models Kit.

Nick Dunhill

Western Thunderer
I am currently building a North British Railway J class (later LNER D29) loco from a N B Models kit in S7.

I build a lot of kits, and lots are challenging. This one is not. This one is the best kit I have made in ages, as good as a MOK or Finney7 kit. Fantastic, accurate etches and quality castings.

It has been a real pleasure to build so far. I had to move the frames outboard slightly to fit S7 wheelsets. The tender body is tricky to form, the etch is bang on accurate though and that helps a lot. The etches for the flare are also bang on, and make a difficult part very easy.

Nothing much to see here. Thanks to Colin Dowling (East Side Pilot) for turning the wheels, and also to Norman Blackburn (Mr N B Models) for providing pics of the prototype and sections of the GA.

53760214003_b34e8fce9d_b.jpg

53759104272_9d79c72605_b.jpg

53759104252_aa14eef3c0_b.jpg

53760213778_2c35db40da_b.jpg

53760342699_5762379157_b.jpg

53760213408_9ce5b2912e_b.jpg

53759103652_ea22b1ed76_b.jpg

53760422765_38dac3f99f_b.jpg
 
Last edited:

Nick Dunhill

Western Thunderer
Well I say S7 is easy, building the locos isn't too difficult, and S7 folks don't expect trains to go round a dinner plate radius curve. This makes building an S7 loco easier in lots of ways. I'm willing to bet that laying track is another, much trickier, ball game though.

I'm willing to bet that the issues with S7 stem from poor trackwork rather than the locos.
 

Nick Dunhill

Western Thunderer
With a finished tender on the window sill I moved on to the loco.

53775950848_85403d9edf_b.jpg

I looked at etches and realised that the sections of the chassis above the footplate (that attach to the footplate) are at prototypical spacing. The rest of the chassis (that we usually make as a separate part of the model) is FS, and a fair bit narrower by 3.1 mm. I thought that S7 would accommodate nearly prototypical spacing, so elected to set the outside frame spacing below the footplate to 30 mm and adjust very slightly above the footplate. This will probably involve narrowing the smokebox base very slightly too. The chassis above and below the footplate will now coincide, which is handy, as we are fitting inside motion, and therefore we will look there.

Another complication is that the chassis at the front is completely scalloped to allow the bogie wheels to pass under the frames, and in real life the chassis was partly 'solid' behind the wheels.

I also needed the front driving/crank axle to be removable.

53775547081_d4561a806c_b.jpg

53775967370_55d79b3e15_b.jpg

You can see above how I have modified the castings and etches to accommodate a Slater's square brass horn block, with the outer face flush with the outer face of the chassis. I also cheated in-filling the chassis behind the bogie wheels. I dished them slightly to give me 1.5 mm clearance on each side. I move the bogie pivot back by 3 mm to stop the rear bogie axle travelling quite so far, and angled the front of the chassis (forward of the cylinder block) inwards by about 1 mm on each side. This should give a generous sideplay for the bogie in S7....hopefully.

I made new frame stays to suit the new chassis spacing and modified the etches for the motion bracket and cylinder rear. I also began making a cylinder front. Here's the chassis being assembled on a pair of parallels sat on plate glass. The graph paper is to allow a check by eye for squareness.

53775547351_6921b76533_b.jpg

I also made the basic footplate and bogie. The bogie has an extended chassis stay.

53775967695_d3503d4811_b.jpg

The modifications seem pretty extensive, but I'm confident that if you were building in FS the etches would have just fallen together as did those for the tender. The job just got a bit harder because I chose to take advantage of the S7 clearances.

Next week I will fit up the drivers, fit the bogie and check for free running. Hopefully I can fit up the inside motion too.
 

Nick Dunhill

Western Thunderer
This week's efforts began by cutting out and installing a cylinder front and bottom. I also added the front and sides of the ashpan from the kit. As I had widened the frames significantly, I had to cut out new ashpan doors and a floor.

53791463193_d3aec9f00b_b.jpg

When the ashpan was finished, I used the coupling rods as a jig to instal the front driving wheel axleboxes.

53791251051_21471faaa1_b.jpg

53791667265_1d8c7f6269_b.jpg

53791463353_eae2b808d4_b.jpg

The wheelsets were installed and checked for free running, and all was well without any adjustments. I like it when that happens.

Much of the rest of the week was then spent preparing bits for the Stephenson Link motion. I still prefer to use Laurie Griffin castings for the crank webs and eccentric rods. The moulds for the waxes for these parts would surely benefit from a refresh, as the castings are a bit poor now, and require quite a bit of fettling. Etchings for the rods would be preferable, but I suppose fettling the laminations would take just as long. The cast eccentrics available from Laurie are too big for his cast eccentric straps (!) and I had some slightly undersized ones machined ages ago, that make the job much easier.

53791559284_b4603734d7_b.jpg

53791559214_8fab4644ab_b.jpg

I installed the etched slide bars provided in the kit. I also used the cast white metal crossheads, and valve rods, provided, even though they were only intended to be used in dummy valve gear. They are a very nice fit and don't bear any load, so I think wear will be minimal when lubricated.

53791463433_3c79e61023_b.jpg

53791559284_b4603734d7_b.jpg

The connecting rod etchings in the kit made some nice components. The big ends did need to be modified slightly to fit round the crankpin journals, and I made the big end eyes too big in diameter. When running the motion made quite a distinctive knocking, similar to an old Triumph 3TA I used to own that had knackered big end bearings. I will adjust or pack with grease later.

I soldered up a crank axle and cut out the axle sections.

53790300857_d2034e4463_b.jpg

The last job before assembly was to make a new weighshaft and counter balances.

53790300892_ff23777e8c_b.jpg

I installed the eccentric rods first, and to my delight they worked perfectly first time, without adjustments. I did a little victory dance round my workshop, and installed the con rods. They knocked badly! (see above.) They did however run freely, without any binding, giving rise to victory dance #2.


As I was finishing the second dance the letter box rattled, and a package containing a pair of modified axles and some 3D printed valve chest covers dropped (cheers Mickoo.) I like JIT deliveries (take note ABC!) I quickly installed the wheels in the bogie and fabricated a bogie mount below the cylinders. I popped the finished chassis on the test track (S7, ambitious 5' 6'' rad!) and it worked with only a minor mod to the front of the chassis to give the front bogie wheel a smidge more clearence. I really was on a roll, dance #3 ensued.


You can hear the knocky big end when the loco is running forwards! If it had been a BR Austerity 2-8-0 loco I would leave it as an authentic sound. I understand drivers up here in the North Country referred to Austerities as 'Bump-Clanks!'

I made the steam reverser from the parts in the kit, but ran out of working-week in which to fit the assembly.

53790301142_bee86a7f73_b.jpg

This is where I will begin next week.
 

Nick Dunhill

Western Thunderer
So this week I have just steamed along with the build. The kit is exceptionally accurate, so it is a doddle (as with all kits a fair amount of care is needed, as mistakes do make inaccuracies multiply.)

Why aren't all kits like this?

I already had the footplate made and just followed the instructions and added the splashers and cab skeleton.

53805334537_f3f3f37769_b.jpg

I had made a few modifications to the chassis, which is now prototypical spacing (S7.) I had to match up the bit of the chassis sticking out above the footplate, and this involved making some infil pieces.

53806707140_c902134156_b.jpg

53806596489_1436e1db04_b.jpg

As you can see I have cut out and added the inside faces of the splashers, there were none in the kit. I wasn't sure if the back of the wheels are visible if you peer under the boiler, and I won't be until the boiler is fitted, at which point it is very difficult to fit the panels.

I have just motored on adding castings and etchings from the kit, and they all fit perfectly. If I'm going to be hyper critical, the hole in the footplate for the sandbox filler was in the wrong place, and one of the slots in the skeleton for the smokebox was etched in the wrong place. The smokebox was sooo easy to make.....if you're careful.

53806707250_2430e25c34_b.jpg

53806596639_676c529f52_b.jpg

Next week I may well finish. Or maybe ABC will send out a gearbox that's holding up a job, or maybe that will only happen when Sheffield Wednesday win the Premier League. We live in hope.
 

Nick Dunhill

Western Thunderer
Other models have retured from paint, so I only managed a couple of days on the D29 this week. Also a motor bogie appeared from ABC!

PREMIER LEAGUE 2026-27
1. Sheffield Wednesday P38 Pts 101
2. Manchester City P38 Pts 98
3. Liverpool P38 Pts 97

The cab front was very easy to attach, and the splasher tops were much easier than they look. I added some splasher steps, and built the cab roof.

The cab interior etches were so accurate that I was able to assemble the structure outside the cab and slot it in. A perfect fit. More next week.

53821888464_da930e0193_b.jpg

53821888509_3cd555281f_b.jpg

53821552931_ec32ed7ff7_b.jpg

Easy, easy easy blah blah......
 
Top